All articles

SAT or ACT: Which Test Should Your Student Take?

Parents often ask whether the SAT or the ACT is the better choice. This post explains the main differences between the two tests and gives you a simple way to decide. You will also see why a practice test of each is worth more than any general advice.

The short answer

Most colleges that ask for test scores will accept either the SAT or the ACT, so neither test is automatically better. The right choice is the one where your student can show their strengths. That depends on how they read, how they work under time pressure and how they feel about science and math.

Some students already know which test they lean toward because of a class they enjoy or a friend's experience. Treat that as a starting point, not a verdict, and test it against real practice results before you build a study schedule around it.

Requirements change from school to school and from year to year, so check the admissions page of each college on your student's list before you settle on a test. Some schools do not ask for scores at all.

What the two tests have in common

Both tests measure reading, writing and math, and both reward students who know the material and manage their time. Both are used by colleges as one piece of an application, alongside grades, essays and activities.

Both tests also reward familiarity. A student who has seen the question styles, the instructions and the pacing before test day is calmer and wastes less time. That is a big reason practice under real conditions matters more than most parents expect.

The ACT also includes a science section, and both tests offer an optional essay at some schools or test dates. The SAT and the ACT are run by different organizations, so it is worth reading the current format on each official site rather than relying on an old brochure or a friend's memory.

Where students feel the difference

Pace is the difference students mention most. Some students find one test rushed and the other roomy. A student who reads carefully and slowly may feel the pressure on one format more than the other, while a student who likes quick, direct questions may prefer the opposite.

Reading stamina is worth a note too. Long passages tire some students by the end of a section, and that shows up in the last few questions. A full practice test reveals whether that is happening and whether timing strategy can fix it.

The science section on the ACT is another point. It leans on reading charts, comparing experiments and reasoning through data, more than on recalling facts. A student who enjoys that kind of thinking may like it. A student who freezes at graphs may want to know that before test day.

A simple way to decide

Have your student sit one full-length practice test of each, under real timing, in a quiet room. Then compare the results and, just as important, how each test felt. Which one ran out of time? Which one felt more familiar? Which section drained them most?

Try to schedule the practice tests a week or two apart so your student is not exhausted, and go over the answers together afterward. The review is where most of the learning happens, so do not skip it.

If the scores come out close, pick the test whose format your student prefers. Motivation matters, and a student who dislikes a test will find it harder to put in the weeks of practice that improve a score.

Then build a plan around the choice

Once you have picked a test, the next step is to find where points are being lost. A practice test shows which sections need work, and that decides how a prep plan should be built. A student weak in algebra needs a different plan from one who loses points on reading passages.

Give yourself enough runway as well. Starting prep several months before the first test date leaves room to retest if needed, and it spreads the work out so your student is not cramming in the final weeks.

At SQUARE D Academy, the SAT/ACT prep course runs 100 hours across reading, writing, math, science and essay, with free practice labs and full-length practice tests to track progress. If you are in Ajax and want to talk through the SAT and the ACT for your student, call us and we will help you plan the next step.